This form of discipline, however, can create potential problems. Jul 01, 2016 very important parents video series 2. Ask, how can i arrange for my child to experience the social consequences of his behavior without forcing, fighting, coercing, or punishing. For this reason, natural consequences are always beneficial but logical consequences may backfire. Natural and logical consequences problem natural or logical.
For example, if a student cuts in front of another student in line, the natural consequence may be that the other child wont play with the. The use of natural and logical consequences encourages your child to take responsibility for his or her own behavior and allows your child to learn from nature and society. In section iii, i shall reconsider those arguments from a. Natural consequences are natural if a child yells at someone that person probably wont be responsive to speaking with you. Behavior plansclassroom and group supportteacher tools. Build the relationship, change the behavior nc state university. A logical consequence for amy would be to take a few minutes to regain control and then to apologize to her classmate. For example, the natural consequence of leaving a bike out for a long period of time. Problemsolving, redirecting your young child to an appropriate activity, and family meetings with kids ages 4 and up, are some examples of strategies that may work when natural consequences wont. For example, linda liked to tap her pencil while doing deskwork.
Since natural and logical consequences make sense, they lead to less resistance and reduce the power struggle. The use of logical consequences is one part of an approach to discipline used in the responsive classroom. It is the responsibility of parents to teach children that behaviors and actions have consequences. The key difference between logical consequences and punishment goes back to the three rs of logical consequences. Natural consequences are things that happen to the child as a result of his or her behavior, without parental involvement. Logical consequences should not be harsh, arbitrary, or inconsistent. Oct 23, 2019 as a general rule, logical consequences are usually the better choice when it comes to a childs health and safety. Logical consequences are created by parents when there are no natural consequences, or when natural consequences are dangerous or inappropriate. While natural consequences happen as a direct result of a childs behavior, without a parent or caregiver having to do anything, logical consequences are created by the parent and should relate to the negative behavior. Parents who use natural and logical consequences are helping teach children that they can control their behaviors and have the power to chose their actions. The goal is to help children recover their selfcontrols and, with guidance, make constructive choices choices that help preserve the integrity of the individual and of.
Definition of consequence natural consequences occur without any enforcement on the part of the parent. If used appropriately, logical consequences should result in rapid changes in the childs behavior within the targeted routine or activity. Logical consequences involve action taken by the parent. An alternative method is called natural and logical consequences and this has certain advantages over reward and punishment. It is important that the child knows they are responsible for their own choices and the natural conse quences that could follow. Again, if you want to learn some positive and very easy parenting techniques, read about using logical and natural consequences rather than punishment, which has been proven to be relatively ineffective and sometimes very damaging in the long term. Jul 31, 2012 natural and logical consequences are an effective way of redirecting negative behaviors because they create the conditions for your child to internalize the lesson learned. Start by marking logical consequences as want to read.
The usual way of disciplining children has been to reward childrens obedience and punish disobedience. The benefits of logical consequences evolutionary parenting. Natural consequences do not work well on younger children. Natural and logical consequences family psychology of. This handy cheat sheet of logical consequences is designed to make classroom management easier than ever. It is important to decide what kind of consequence would create a helpful learning experience that might encourage children to. This post is going to explore consequences for teenagers and how it can improve your relationship with them, while also preparing them for real life. By having your young people consider consequences, theyll be better placed to make informed decisions and make better choices in. If you arent able to use a natural consequence, then try a logical consequence that is clearly tied to the behavior. Preschoolers and young elementary school children lack the ability to understand that the consequence is a direct result of their behavior. This weeks youth work session plan is designed to help youth explore the natural and logical consequences that result from a variety of different behaviors. For consequences to be effective, the children involved must see them as logical. Logical consequences are different from natural consequences in that they require the intervention of an adultor other children in a family meeting or a class meeting. Natural consequences are a very effective form of discipline.
The three rs of logical consequences education world. A consequence is a result of something a person does. Natural and logical consequences natural consequences help correct irresponsible or immature behaviors. Logical consequences should not be used if the child does not understand the options and is not able to make a decision about the action to choose. Remember that the purpose of discipline is to teach or instruct the child selfcontrol and appropriate behavior. Natural consequencesthe painful results of ones actionsare the best teachers of all. In conscious discipline, there are three types of consequences. How to use natural and logical consequences to improve.
Using natural and logical consequences umn extension. Logical consequences some people are confused by the difference between natural and logical consequences. Logical consequences occur as a result of a childs actions, and are carried out by the parent or caregiver as a followup. Then consider logical consequences that are related to the misbehavior. How to explore natural and logical consequences youth. Letting children experience the natural or logical consequences of their actions is one way to teach responsibility. Taking away a privilege for the day could be logically connected to the outburst. Logical consequences, on the other hand, are what are given to a child by a parent or caregiver when the child misbehaves or breaks a rule, and are ideally linked to the bad behavior. In section iii, i shall reconsider those arguments from a permissive view of logical consequence.
The definitions that follow will help with understanding natural and logical consequences and how to apply them. This list of logical consequences for teenagers are the best to prepare them for real life. A list of logical consequences for their actions this post may contain affiliate links where i earn a small comission your purchase at no cost to you. Natural consequences are the inevitable result of a childs own actions. Here are some examples of when natural consequences do not work. Parents can use natural and logical consequences to guide their children, but planning ahead is required to be effective. You can set the expectations ahead of time and implement the consequences when needed e. One of lifes most important lessons is that actions have consequences. Consequences for teenagers i loved the book love and logic. So before you allow natural consequences to happen, make sure your child will be able to safely learn a life lesson. As a general rule, logical consequences are usually the better choice when it comes to a childs health and safety. Consequences are effective only if you avoid having hidden motives of winning and controlling.
Using natural consequences as a discipline strategy. After all, you wouldnt allow a child to not brush her teeth and permit the natural consequencecavitiesto form in her mouth. Here we explain what these types of consequences are and some examples to get you thinking in the right direction. Anything can be abused in practice, and it must be noted that consequences invoked during a power struggle are. Parenting with natural and logical consequences oklahoma.
Again, if you want to learn some positive and very easy parenting techniques, read about using logical and natural consequences rather than punishment, which has been proven to be relatively ineffective and sometimes very damaging in. Distilled from rudolf dreikurs natural and logical. One of lifes important lessons to be learned is that actions have consequences. A natural consequence to leaving the tricycles out on the playground may be that they become wet and cant be used the next day. If the problem behavior persists, the teacher or logical. However, you can see from the examples above that natural consequences do not always deter behavior. Jun 28, 2012 this weeks youth work session plan is designed to help youth explore the natural and logical consequences that result from a variety of different behaviors. If you let a 4yearold choose his own bedtime, he likely wont know hes tired because he stayed up too late.
Natural consequences natural consequences are the naturally occurring result of a childs actions. By having your young people consider consequences, theyll be better placed to make informed decisions and make better choices in the future. Your child must deal with the effects or consequences of an action. If youre trying to create a positive classroom environment, ditch the unrelated punishments and help students connect their behavior to the outcomes. While the actual consequence may be the same in both situations, the way that the teacher presents it to the student and its relation to the inappropriate behavior is what determines whether it. The purpose of using natural and logical consequences is to motivate children to make responsible decisions, not to force their submission. Logical consequences, as discussed in the last article, are ways in which adults structure learning opportunities for children when natural consequences pose too much harm. Nov 27, 2018 in conscious discipline, there are three types of consequences. This material was developed by the center on the social and emotional foundations for early learning with federal funds from the u.
Logical consequences are an alternative to punishment. A tried proven method that has succeeded throughout the edges both in, and outside of the classroom. A parents guide to natural and logical consequences one of lifes important lessons to be learned is that actions have consequences. Taking away a privilege for the day could be logically connected to the outburst but its not a natural outcome it is determined by the parent. Natural and logical consequences make sense as a discipline strategy, but often parents struggle to come up with ideas of their own in the heat of the moment. Letting children experience the natural or logical consequences of their actions is one way to teach. Logical consequences are directly related to childrens behaviors and help them to fix their mistakes. Sep 12, 2019 logical consequences teach students the hows and whys of good decisions, rather than making them sorry for making a bad choice. Logical consequences handout vanderbilt university. Logical consequences in the classroom weareteachers. Logical consequences help guide children in learning how they are expected to behave in the real world. Logical consequences by teacher trap teachers pay teachers. Mom did not force johnny to take his jacket, therefore he got wet when it rained. This method is called natural or logical consequences.
Feel free to check my disclosure and terms for more info. Using logical consequences logical consequences are created by parents when there are no natural consequences. Another form of consequence is logical consequences, where we let the punishment fit the crime. Facilitated effectively, these consequences help children develop an inner moral compass, learn selfregulation, and become responsible citizens. After he is calm and the dust has settled, see if there is a natural consequence for the situation. It is important to decide what kind of consequence would create a helpful learning experience that might encourage children to choose responsible cooperation.
Natural consequences allow discomfort to occur naturally, rather than a parent creating a consequence to teach a lesson. While logical consequences may, at times, overlap with natural consequences, logical consequences involve action taken on the part of parents in response to the behavior of their children. Natural and logical consequences come after the choices children make and are a product of their decisions. Time required 30 to 45 minutes, depending on number of participants core concept parents will plan. Natural and logical consequences using natural consequences. When a child refuses to wear a coat on a rainy day, the natural. Logical consequences are different from natural consequences in that they require the intervention of an adultor other children in a family or a class meeting. When setting consequences for children of any age, they should be logical. Natural consequences, the ones we are addressing now, happen as a result of behavior that are not planned or controlled. Natural consequences natural consequences occur automatically as a result of actions.
If logical consequences are too severe, such as when we rely on spanking or. The three types of consequences and how to give them. Often, allowing the natural consequence to occur will prevent a parentchild argument and the child will learn the right lesson. For example, despite dads urging him to put on his coat, tommy goes outside when its cold without wearing a coat. Natural consequences should be used to teach children to make better choices in the future, not to make them suffer for the mistakes they already made.
Children and sometimes adults dont always make the association between their behaviors actions and the. Ive attached my original brochure which you can feel free to use in any way you like. Using logicalnatural consequences in parenting the use of natural and logical consequences may be appropriate when your childs behavior is unacceptable. Natural and logical consequences problem natural or. Disciplining your child natural and logical consequences. Logical consequences, as we learned in the last two articles, are ways in which adults structure learning opportunities for children. An important piece of establishing a logical consequence is verbally processing both when the behavior is present and after your child has stopped and calmed down. A parents guide to natural and logical consequences. The arguments of section ii will presuppose a restrictive view of logical consequence. In this article, well teach you how and when to use each of the three. The use of natural or logical consequences enhances the childs developing sense of him or herself as a responsible participant in shaping the character of family life, as well as the circumstances of his or her own individual life. Logical consequences using logical consequences should result in rapid changes in the childs behavior within the targeted routine or activity if using logical consequences is not successful, think about why the child is engaging in the challenging behavior and consider other.
395 643 338 676 592 56 1228 278 1040 1096 754 159 612 503 419 18 24 1203 869 287 1168 935 1043 1490 674 1233 634 148 367 1388 894 487